My Kink is Cathartic

The truth behind erotica's mainstream takeover.

By Lilia Santeramo

Remember when your mother was too busy surreptitiously reading Fifty Shades of Grey on the park bench to notice how close you were to breaking your neck in a tumble from the monkey bars? Me either, but such negligence could be listed among the alleged dangers of the consumption of erotic fiction. Tellingly, warnings of these dangers are almost exclusively found online, where talk of erotica is front and center.


While there has always been a market for erotica, its boom in popularity and media coverage in the past few years can largely be attributed to young adults and a smattering of teenagers raving about their favorite “spicy” novels on TikTok, Instagram and YouTube. Series like A Court of Thorns and Roses and authors like Colleen Hoover have enjoyed tremendous yet divisive popularity as a result of online word of mouth. This fanfare has even spread to in-person fan events.


For its part, the publishing industry has responded to the wave of interest in erotic literature by flooding the market, which is easy to do because readers of this genre generally don’t mind formulaic plots and seemingly never tire of the same few tropes popularized in fanfiction. Walk into any bookstore and you'll see them by the dozens: the Canvaesque covers, the floral motifs, the cute displays! Ask anyone on campus, they or someone they know has read more than a few books pulled from such extravagant shelving. 


Ohio University, it so happens, is a central locus for not just recreational but scholarly study of erotica, or as sociology professor Thomas Vander Ven calls it in the research he’s conducting, “smut.”


Vander Ven specializes in crime and deviance and has a background in issues of addiction and recovery in young people. In two separate lectures about cultural ideas surrounding pornography, deviance and addiction, Vander Ven explained that there isn’t a lot known about women’s relationship with visual pornography. In both instances, students approached him after class to suggest looking into women’s relationships with smut. Both students, Carly Andrews and Zainah Al Maita, are now working alongside Vander Ven on research about that very subject. They started with a survey.


“We decided to do a more strategic focused recruitment,” Vander Ven says. “A lot of this is word of mouth. The two young women on the team are smut consumers and a lot of their friends are [too], so they got the word out.”


The 32-question survey became a tool to understand how people who are already smut users, not the general population, think about smut and the role that it plays in their lives. Its findings, which are still preliminary, indicate a few main themes among smut consumers. A substantial percentage of respondents reported using smut for entertainment (66 percent), for sexual objectives (25 percent) and to experiment more in their sex lives (42 percent).


Notably, it is the latter themes that inspire detractors of erotic literature, who are quick to accuse enthusiastic readers of having a porn addiction. 


Vander Ven notes that so far, only a few people expressed feeling like they consumed too much or could not stop consuming erotica despite trying. Meanwhile, there were respondents who said that reading smut allows them to feel safe while “in a way, experiencing a sexual encounter,” and expressed how “reading about a respectful male with deep, loyal and unwavering feelings is refreshing.” Vander Ven also mentions that, like visual pornography, smut can be used as part of a couple’s sex life in a functional and healthy way. 


Other criticism may come from classically misogynistic ideas about women and purity. Vander Ven found that so far, 82 percent of survey respondents agreed that it’s more acceptable for men to consume visual pornography than women. More and more women are open about the way they engage with sexually explicit material, but there’s still a stigma around women openly expressing their desires.


Despite that stigma, Vander Ven says that readers of smut exhibit a great deal of socially healthy, community-oriented behaviors surrounding the activity like enthusiastic recommendations, book clubs and themed events. He stresses that people who are trepidatious about trends in erotica’s popularity shouldn’t worry. Unlike trends in consumption habits around visual porn observed in young men, young women don’t seem to be engaging with the genre in shame and isolation, nor are they acting out antisocial dynamics that normalize sexual coercion.

 

“It's a social thing. They're meeting each other, and it's part of their friendships. It may actually help to improve their relationships,” Vander Ven says.


If people aren’t prudishly wringing their hands about erotica in general, they might fret about the genre as it relates to a general decline of critical thinking and literacy. Erotica isn’t literature, which is apparently the only acceptable thing to read in a time when people are reading less and less. But an argument can be made that aside from offering entertainment, erotica allows for exploration of important themes.


Mallory Boring, a third-year doctoral student, is researching 18th- and 19th-century literature and contemporary literature set in the Regency period. She is interested in exploring the different ways writers have thought about courtship. Boring is in the process of reading early novels that navigate ideas about morality and obstacles in relationships and comparing them to contemporary novels that are more interested in the process of romance and the intricacies that come with representing a broader range of lived experiences. 


“I think when it comes to romance novels in particular, they say a lot about love, but also who is worth loving, who is an object of desire for people,” Boring says. So, I think [love in novels] holds serious weight when it comes to the matter of who's being represented. I think it also helps us build a societal understanding of what love looks like and should look like.” 


While Boring’s work deals with romance novels, her observations about relationships wrestle with and help us understand love and desire as they manifest in our cultural moments, suggesting the works have a seriousness that isn’t exclusive to romance, even if that seriousness manifests differently. 


“There are conventions and everything, but I think romance gets the crap that it gets because women tend to like it more; it's happy and positive, and people consider that less serious,”  Boring says. “But I don't know what would be more serious than love and human relationships in that same vein.” Surely this sentiment can be extended to erotica.


Grace Anne Gasperson, who recently graduated from Ohio University with a bachelor’s degree in classics and religious studies, isn’t an avid reader of erotica, but she has several friends online who enjoy the genre and discuss it with her. The conversations are often humorous and contain “filthy screenshots,” but Gasperson notices that the works express common themes that transcend the acts they snicker about. 


“I think the biggest fantasy in those books is not actually the sex,” Gasperson says. “I think it's being able to step back.”


What she means is that the novels, especially the fantasy-oriented ones, often have hard-working, competent women who reach a point where they’ve done enough and need someone to recognize their work and step in.


“I think especially [for] women, [romantasy is] a space where they can be the focus of care in a way that I think women don't expect to be in their lives or even their relationships,” Gasperson says.  


So, young women are encouraging one another to explore their fantasies with humor, without shame and without apology. They’re expressing themselves and thinking about different ways of negotiating the complexities of desire, sex and relationships. Maybe the writing isn’t all that great, but it’s nothing to turn one’s nose up at.


Next
Next

Let’s Talk About Sex